“Inside, I too was burning. There was something in my chest, what felt like grief and pain at the same time. I was unsettled deep inside, in my veins, in my limbs, in the fibers lacing around my ribs and connecting to my lungs.” (Page 43)
Author Elizabeth Kadetsky offers a personal narrative that also tells the story of B.K.S. Iyengar and the journey of the yoga tradition to the West. It’s a well-written and engaging book that mixes just enough of Kedetsky’s own story to keep things interesting while remaining true to the book’s intent.
There were definitely things to like about the book. I learned a lot about the background and life of yoga master B.K.S. Iyengar. The ‘behind-the-scenes’ peek at his Yoga Institute in Pune was intriguing. Kadetsky is a good writer. The narrative brings the reader along, walking the halls, peeking in rooms and dark corners, scanning titles in the library. It’s like a keyhole into a fascinating hidden world. Her descriptions of the people are vivid and honest. The author has a gift for revealing the hidden weaknesses of people in a sensitive way that bring the reader closer, allows for a sort of intimacy.
The author doesn’t hesitate to turn this scrutiny on herself. She reveals her personal history of family conflicts, overwork and anorexia and shares her thoughts about how yoga helped her to delve into her own darkness and emerge triumphant. When faced with contradictions between her work as a journalist versus her role as a yoga student, she’s honest and upfront, clearly delineating the boundaries and where she crosses the line. These moments are some of the most fascinating in the book.
For anyone who’s been in the yoga community for a number of years, this book is fun for it’s gossip value. It’s like sitting down with a group of fellow yoga teachers over coffee and gabbing about who’s doing what and teaching where. Two of my teachers studied with Iyengar in India, so I had already heard the stories, but they were one-dimensional. It was fun to hear another perspective.
I was bothered by a few aspects of the book. The author gives a lot of historical background on the development of the yoga tradition in the West – bascially, in the United States. In the book, she argues that yoga is really a modern tradition and questions those who claim a 5000 year history.
This is where it gets tricky. Yoga is defined very differently in the US vs. India and in your neighbourhood gym vs. an ashram. Yoga in the modern, western sense is a series of physical postures which may or many not be accompanied by breathing exercises and meditation. Yoga in the Indian sense is a purely philosophical system. The physical postures (asana), breathing exercises (pranayama) and even meditation, are only small aspects of the system as a whole. Yoga Philosophy has its roots in the Vedas, written nearly 5000 years ago. Hatha yoga, Astanga yoga, Bikram yoga, Kundalini yoga, Anusara yoga, Vini yoga, Sivananda yoga ( and the list goes on; I know I’ve probably forgetten at least 5 yogas) are all fairly modern interpretations of the physical practice of yoga, referred to as ‘Asana’ in Patanjali’s yoga sutra.
The author doesn’t make this distinction, which can leave the reader with the impression that yoga is nothing more than a series postures that were included in a few books in the 19th century and fleshed out in the 20th. The book seems to imply that masters such as Iyengar and Pattabhi Jois (the guru of Astanga yoga in Mysore, India) are simply good businessmen who took an idea and marketed the hell out of it. She stops just short of saying that yoga is a big fake.
With her access to Iyengar, his writings and his entire library of Yoga Philosophy, I’m surprised that the author didn’t at least give a nod to yoga’s philosophical roots. I’m particularly distressed because many people who might not know very much about yoga (yoga the philsophy and yoga the system of physical postures) may get a skewed idea of its importance and meaning. It’s troubling omission and it prevents me from recommending this book whole-heartedly.