I liked this book somewhat less than the previous ones, but still more than your average book. What I like about these young women is that they have real-ish lives and INNER LIVES even, not the stereotypical “Shoes! Boys! School is hard!” mentality of so much fiction aimed at young women. They deal with the kinds of problems that real people deal with. They have boy problems, yes, but also intellectual and creative aspirations, troubled families, and recurring personality flaws or weaknesses. They travel and learn things and get depressed. Also, in the most recent one, they have sex, and sometimes it is a good thing, and sometimes not; also they sometimes don’t have sex, and that is sometimes a good thing too.
The books don’t talk down to their characters, or to their readers. For writing relatively non-patronizing and sophisticated young adult fiction, Ann Brashares, I salute you.