so…yea. saw this in the movie store, and i thought, hmmm…ok. musical written and directed by john turturro. now, i love john turturro, but..there seems to be more of these popping up, these high art films written and directed by established actors. i understand why, if i was an intelligent actor of course i’d want to write and direct my own movie..but that doesnt mean its gonna be any good.
not that this isnt any good, its just..i dunno. style over substance, thats the problem. theres lots of interesting scenes and lines, but the underlying storyline is..i dunno, just not that good. it is interesting though, because its not really a musical..but it is. with the amount of storyline covered, its very similar to a musical. but theres not very many scenes with the actors singing directly to the camera, not as many as im accustomed to in a “normal” musical. and theyre singing over the original recording, so it somehow doesnt seem as grating as watching people who arent really singers be made to sing as part of their role.
theres some brilliant performances here, but..i dont know why. its like john turturro called all the people he knows and likes in his magic hollywood book, and just threw them in places. christopher walken is totally uncomfortable, mary-louise parker and eddie izzard are completely wasted, mandy moore seems like a weird afterthought..a very interesting cast, pretty much ignored for james gandolfini, who i just dont like that much. kate winslet was borderline super-annoying, and susan sarandon..well shes good, but pretty quiet.
this movie was trying to do waaay too many things at once, and while the humor comes across, the drama never really cuts through. plus theres a whole slew of things that get left by the wayside to focus on what happens to the husband, very male-centric. also, a tad long.
see, i say all these bad things, but really its just an interesting, funny, weird musical thing, and totally worth watching. but i will admit, i was a bit disappointed.