Not my usual reading material. However, this book managed to keep me reading, and I cared about the antagonist the whole way through. The metaphysics left me hanging a bit, but enjoyed the read.

I really enjoyed this book. I recently purchased a new copy, since my old copy was in terrible shape. I plan on re-reading it on a several year interval.

I am collecting works on blacksmithing and metalworking. Someday I hope to put some of that book learning to hobby use.

I am collecting works on blacksmithing and metalworking. Someday I hope to put some of that book learning to hobby use.

A buddy in college had a role playing game based on the world in these books. Although I never gamed in his world, the story really interested me. Besides, this series seems to be one of the best rated in SciFi.

This was the first Recluce book I ever read.
Magic and blacksmithing technology mix elegantly.
The depth of the characters makes them believable, and the description emerges the reader in the world.

Although I was disappointed with the first novel in the series, I persevered due to the strength of the third novel. I was rewarded by the second book, however, this fourth in the series disappointed. I am concerned because this book actually comes before the first chronologically. I will likely not purchase any more in this series.

Finishing the series for the second time.

Some very interesting books and tools. Some very wrong predictions.

I am reviewing this book for the publisher.