Could have been better — 3 years ago
It’s an intriguing concept: Charles Lindbergh has defeated Roosevelt and the United States becomes an isolationist country (with Nazi sympathies) during World War II, but Roth’s story (told by a 9-to-11-year-old version of himself) drags throughout the novel. Unfortunately, telling it from the point of view of a child without many insights from his adult self is what keeps the book from picking up velocity. Young Philip’s musings about his stamp book and his various family members bog the book down in superfluous details. While yes, the book is an alternate family history as well as an Orwellian account of what America could have been in the 1940s, I found myself craving for more news of what was happening in Europe throughout the book instead of hearing family members whine about their fates over and over again.
In sum, I’m not disappointed I read it; it’s definitely worth a skim, but it doesn’t deserve all the acclaim it’s been getting, that’s for sure.

