(Originally posted on Copper Press’ The Daily Copper.)
No man is an island, they say, but Jason Martin (who for all intents and purposes is Starflyer 59) has been following his own whims and impulses for the past thirteen years and ten albums - all on Tooth & Nail - regardless of the musical zeitgeist. For that reason, the band that started out with a thick shoegazer sound to suit its sci-fi name has drifted far to either side of its original course, yet always a hair’s breadth outside the scope of whatever tracking system the music industry uses to select its darlings.
Even with Martin’s fickle and versatile musical nature in mind, My Island is not the album many current Starflyer 59 fans would have easily seen coming. It’s clearly in the same lineage as 2005’s Talking Voice vs. Singing Voice, but it’s a darker, more bass-driven and straight-ahead rock ‘n’ roll effort than earlier dream pop albums like Leave Here a Stranger (2001), with occasional new wave keyboards replacing the lavish synths of Everybody Makes Mistakes (1999) and string arrangements of Talking Voice. You might even call My Island a melding of the two dominant phases of the band’s existence, uniting the softer pop of recent years with the weightier guitar sound of Gold (1995), Americana (1997), and the would-be Americana follow-up, I Am the Portuguese Blues (2004). As always, though, Martin’s strong, simple melodies are the backbone of the album, with everything else merely draped over it ornamentally.
“The Frontman” and “Division” are two different sides of this new-ish direction for Martin, one driving and almost sinister, the other slow and menacing. What they both have in common is that sinister/menacing element, which runs through the first half of the My Island. Only with the gritty guitar and metronomic drum thwack of “Mic the Mic” does the mood break, and it no longer feels as tough Martin is making ominous pronouncements from behind steepled fingers in a smoke-filled room. But even though these foremost tracks set a shadowy tone, a first impression that tends to obscure more reservedly upbeat songs like “It’s Alright Blondie” and the title track, they’re some the some of the most memorable on the disc. Of these “Nice Guy” is the instant standout, a song that walks the fine line between bass-heavy rock song and dark dance track, a bit like “Good Sons” from Talking Voice.
For all its strengths, My Island nevertheless has an overly clean, clinical production that has affected a number of self-produced Starflyer 59 releases since Gene Eugene’s death in 2000. To say that it detracts in any significant way from yet another excellent Starflyer 59 album would be reckless exaggeration. This is the sort of quality most bands would like to hit on just one disc in their entire history; Jason Martin has achieved it with nearly everything he’s put out under the Starflyer 59 name, no matter which personal whim he happens to be indulging at the moment.