I’ve become a big fan of Greg Rucka the past couple of years—his work on Wonder Woman and Adventures of Superman have been especially great. However, I’m becoming less and less fond of his DC spy stuff.
Checkmate spins out of the OMAC Project, Rucka’s prequel to Infinite Crisis which reestablished Checkmate as a nebulous international spy organization. Post-Infinite Crisis, Checkmate is a U.N.-sanctioned group that protects the world from super-powered threats.
Rucka takes on a bunch of small characters from the DC Universe (the original Green Lantern, Mister Terrific, Count Vertigo, Amanda Waller, etc.) to form the spy organization. The first four issues show the machinations of keeping the group solvent from a threat from the Chinese to veto Checkmate’s charter. The last three issues… are a digression.
I’m annoyed by all the aspects of Checkmate that seem to come from the Marvel Universe. The whole naming system-characters are called the white and black king and queen-reminds me of the Hellfire Club, Checkmate itself seems a lot like SHIELD, and one of the villains, Kobra, looks a lot like HYDRA or at least the Serpent Society. These aren’t exactly mainstream Marvel properties, but Rucka didn’t do much to distinguish his characters as unique.
There are just too many characters in this book. There are some nice parts, especially the negotiating in the U.N., and some of the Chinese superheroes. The last two issues, a Suicide Squad story, add little but clutter to the book.
From reading Queen and Country, I know Rucka can do espionage well, but Checkmate isn’t a good showing.