I’m sad to have to return this book to the library tomorrow because I can’t stop going back to it even after two full reads. Having known nothing previously of the early 20th century French photographer Eugene Atget I now find myself slightly obsessed with this collection of 100 plates, all superbly informed by John Szarkowski.
It’s not that the photographs are beautiful, or perfectly exposed, or technically marvelous. In fact, I think it’s Szarkowski’s writing about Atget’s photos that is the real treasure of this book. Without his context, I wouldn’t really be able to see the photos.
For instance, near the end of the book there is a photo of a department store window. At this late point in Atget’s career as a commercial photographer he seemed more interested in creating artful representations of his world rather than straight-forward photos he could later sell. It’s really one of the most beautiful photos in the book. There are four female mannequins posed in a variety of coats and frocks. On the window there is the dark refection of the Gobelins factories across the street. Szarkowski explains that Atget was likely offended in a Old World way by the department store display and then postulates that “it is wrong and self-defeating to photograph badly the subjects of which one disapproves. In fact, for a photographer as serious as Atget, it might be necessary to photograph a subject as well as he can before he knows what he thinks of it.” That is simply brilliant. More books by John Szarkowski will added post haste to my reading list.