All Consuming


6 out of 6 people (100%) think this is worth consuming…

0312424930
Balkan Ghosts: A Journey Through History
by Robert D. Kaplan
See this at Amazon.com

9 people have consumed this.

People consuming this are also consuming these items.

2 entries have been written about this.

qatesiurade
Cheyenne

Moving and evocative — 1 year ago

WORTH CONSUMING!

I picked this up solely on the strength of Robert D. Kaplan’s later work, An Empire Wilderness, one of the best books about travel in America’s heartland I’ve ever read. Balkan Ghosts did not disappoint!

I agree with the other reviewer that the first section, on the former Yugoslavia, had the least impact, but I think a lot of this is due to the power of the other sections; it suffers by contrast. It’s still a great probing into what a mess this part of the world really is, and why it is, and how it got to be that way, and why it’s a task beyond most if not all imaginations to ever satisfactorily tidy it up; Tito just clamped a lid down and let it stew and now it’s frothing over. How are we going to do it better or different (for another look at this area, I’d strongly recommend Joe Sacco’s Safe Area Gorazde).

The sections on Bulgraria and Romania pull off the difficult trick of de-romanticizing these places—and then making them romantic all over again in a new way. I fell in love with the same people Kaplan did, especially his friend Guillermo.

Strangely, I find the last section, on Greece, to be less engaging. I say strangely because he did live there after all - but the story here becomes much more of a dreary rehashing of recent Greek history. Still very informative - I’d always vaguely known Greece was another mess that had been glossed over but not to this degree. And he succeeds in making the argument that Greece is a Balkan country more than a Mediterranean one (though my Mom told me that decades ago—but I’ve an unusual mother).

All in all… this is a library book I checked out that I can just tell I’m going to end up hunting down in hardcover for my personal library because I’ll want to re-read it a lot.

megz4716
Vancouver

Why I recommend this — 2 years ago

WORTH CONSUMING!

This book provides a decent historical overview of the conflict in the Balkans in the 1990s with perspective from locals of all walks of life, and manages to successfully integrate factual history with personal travelogue in a sincere and interesting manner. The sections on Romania and Bulgaria are especially poignant, although the section on the former Yugoslavia and Albania is a bit disinterested…you can tell these countries did not mean as much personally to Kaplan as Romania and Bulgaria. Great for an armchair traveler or casual historian.


FAQ | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | | Robot Co-op Blog | Copyright © 2004 - 2009 Robot Co-op