All Consuming

2708 out of 3109 people (87%) think this is worth consuming…

The Catcher in the Rye
by J. D. Salinger
See this at

5878 people have consumed this.

See all 5878 people who have consumed this

9 entries have been written about this.

A review of this — 1 year ago


The last few chapters had some wisdom but other than that i just couldn’t enjoy this book. I kept waiting for something to happen but nothing ever did. Maybe if he came to some sort of realization at the end of the book, it could have been worth it.

Why I recommend this — 2 years ago



First Salinger I picked up, so I was struck by the book’s bold tone. Holden’s fresh frankness and disillusionment makes it resonate with every American teen for some period of time. Got sick of him about halfway through, but I can still imagine him neurotically buffing bathroom graffiti from time to time.

A story about this — 6 years ago

The best I can think to say about this is that it’s a quick read. I guess there was something to it, but really it was a bit grating. In terms of writing though, it was 100 per cent what it set out to be, and the character never wavered. So while I can see the skill, I guess, I didn’t really enjoy the experience.

A story about this — 6 years ago


I hated this book. I tried hard to like it, but if I wanted to hear the plight of a whining teenager, I could just call one of my friends and listen to them talk.

A story about this — 6 years ago


Some time ago we were reading this book in class and I noticed something funny. Either someone loved it or hated it, but no one stayed indifferent.

A review of this — 7 years ago


I was really glad to have finally read this book, it was sitting on the shelf for years, I kid you not.

Anyway, it always kind of struck me as a book for reading in school, I don’t really know why that would be.

So I read it, I had no expectations of it, I like when I have no expectations of something, that way you can’t be dissapointed. Well, it didn’t really go anywhere, so I can see why someone would be kind of let down with it, but I saw it more as a snapshot of the guys life. Like how he came to realise certain things about him in a very short space of time, I like how he learns as he goes along in his rather haphazard way. He is so typical of us all at that sort of age, you don’t see more than you want to, but it sort of happens to you anyhow, I don’t know if that makes any sense at all, I have had 2 bottles of Grolsch whilst watching the rugby…

Please end the torture... — 7 years ago


I wanted to read this because I seem to be the only person on the planet who didn’t read it in high school, but…

Ugh! Why on earth is this a “classic”?!? By the time I hit page 15 I was already flipping ahead to see how long it was and if the incessant whining ever stopped. I forced myself to finish it because it is a “classic” but I wanted to claw my eyes out the whole time. I started thinking that maybe this is a book that only appeals to teenagers, but then I realized that even if I had read it ten years ago I still wouldn’t have related. (maybe my reaction would have been less violent, though)

Why I recommend this — 7 years ago


I was reading and reading and got to page 50…100…200…and couldn’t figure out why people said it was a masterpiece, but I kept reading. It took until page 224, but that page changed everything for me. After reading the part where Holden tells Phoebe he wants to be the catcher in the rye, I was able to look back on the entire novel and realize why it was worth reading, and I realized that this is one of my favorite books of all time.

Picks up near the end — 7 years ago


I liked it. It was hard to get through at the beginning, but I think there’s a good reason: I’m 20. My best friend put it best when she said “I would have loved it if I was 13.” I would have idolized Holden and his independence and his flying by the seat of his pants. But I didn’t. It was a good read, though. I just would have loved to see an adjective other than “crumby,” “phony,” or the occaisonal “vomity.” But once it got to the point where the title is explained, it really picked up. There’s some deep stuff hidden in there. Not a life-changer, but I was glad to have read it.

FAQ | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Send Us Feedback | Robot Co-op Blog | Copyright © 2004 - 2014 Robot Co-op

Login with Facebook