I love these two books! I think writing them was an genius idea, both for us the frantic fans and for Comic Relief. I hope JKR does something else like that. This book is better than the onther one in my opinion because it reads almost like a real history book. The writing style is interesting and the facts are great – it’s so cool that JK knows enough about her world to be able to write things like that. If you’re a big fan, this is a must. The Hogwarts crest, the list of people who have borrowed the book and the foreword by Dumbledore (“it is of course an entirely fictional sport and nobody really plays it”) are all great additions.