I actually ended up buying Staples Business Depot paper: 500 sheets, 100% post-consumer, for 4,97. Pretty darn good price! My fiancee saw it on sale, I was so happy!

100% Post-Consumer recycled paper is SO MUCH BETTER for the environment and I URGE people to buy them! Everybody needs to help reduce/stop this serious threat that is global warming.

It costs much less to manufacture because the companies reuse what people like you and me have used and put in the recycling and making into new, instead of making new from scratch: it uses less water and energy, makes less pollution, saves valuable resources, etc.

Printing paper I have found:

Boise Aspen (100% recycled paper – not Post-Consumer – but it’s a start)
Neenah Paper
Eureka

I’ve been looking online for more paper companies and I can’t find any. There doesn’t seem to be a lot of them.