There’s little I can add to the rapturous reviews of Philip Gröning’s Into Great Silence- an almost three-hour documentary on a Carthusian monastery in France and its monks who have taken a vow to live their lives as silently as possible. It’s not nearly as forbidding as it sounds, even if there is no voiceover narration, or hardly any subtitles - there is no need for them for the most part—or no artificial light. (Some of the most beautiful passages in the film are set at Vespers, sometimes lit only by a lone candle.)

The monks do speak, for starters, and the part Gröning chooses to show is their rather funny quibbling about certain rituals. But immediately, at the beginning of the film, the audience is already drawn into contemplation: we watch a monk, barely discernible in the dim light, kneeling in prayer, for about half a minute; he stands, adjusts the heater in his bare room, and kneels again.

The theme of the eternal present is movingly raised by an elderly blind monk, testifying joyfully about his blindness and his peaceful embrace of his mortality. There are no distinctions between past or present with God, the monk says; only the present prevails, and when He sees us, he always sees our entire life. In contrast, the ineluctable passage of time is seen outside the monastery: seasons follow one another, the snows end and the blooms appear. (Gröning also presents the monks not as timeless, ahistorical figures: one monk puzzles over bills on an IBM Thinkpad, another practices his singing on a small keyboard, airplanes fly overhead.)

The cinematography, both intimate and grand, is something else: some high-definition video shots echo the Old Masters in their composition; we see, in painstaking detail, new leaves peeking through still-frosted stems, or the slow drop of water from a bucket. (Indeed, the swarming motes in the grainy Super-8 footage - sometimes, of nothing but blue sky or gray cloud - suggest a perpetual movement in what is ostensibly still.) Gröning also gets a lot of mileage from close-ups of shaved heads, the camera peering over monks’ shoulders as they read or pray, inviting the audience to imagine the secrets inside their skulls, to wonder about what inspires such devotion.

Viewers will come away with different things. For me it was the effortless way in which the deeply ordinary was invested with a deep, spiritual gravity; they shovel snow, feed cats, saw wood, sing, and kneel in prayer, and somehow the divine is felt as a trace, lingering in all their labors. There is a scene, for instance, in which a monk repairs a shoe, and his simple act of blowing on the glue to dry it becomes, in the world of Into Great Silence, the seeming exhalation of a prayer. The less generous will wonder about the political implications of a retreat from all the sorrows of the world. But many will surely remark upon the temporary transformation of the movie theater into an extension of the monastery; indeed, the hush follows you outside into the night as you leave.

A thought provoking documentary about the daily routines and rhythms of ascetic Carthusian Order monks residing in the Grande Chartreuse monastery in the Alps. Over its three hours, there’s barely any dialogue, no music and huge expanses of silence. It’s a hard film to sit through as absolutely nothing happens (in the traditional cinematic sense).

We watch the monks go about their everyday business: sweeping floors, cutting hair, praying, planting vegetables. There’s no real structure except for the psalm like quotations that appear on screen to divide up the various sections of the work. We never learn anything about the monks or the monastery itself, there’s nothing to involve or attach yourself to.

However, as tedious as it is to watch, the film does trigger off questions about the nature of religion, ritual and what it means to dedicate yourself to a way of life that, from the outside, seems archaic and dare I say it psychotic. Into Great Silence is like a piece of video art that you may see in a gallery: it unfolds and unfurls but ultimately fails to engage you in its own process.

It feels like a vital opportunity was lost in this film. Cinematically speaking, I found many of the images drawn upon (snowflakes, icicles, clouds) to be rather banal. There was a real failure to illustrate the internal, transcendent states that these holy practitioners reach.
There’s more info about the film here: http://www.diegrossestille.de/english/ including an interview with the director who explains why he approached the film in the way he did.

Worth seeing if only to make up your own mind about this peculiar and idiosyncratic film, which has won many plaudits and awards wherever it has been shown.