All Consuming


59 out of 64 people (92%) think this is worth consuming…


The Phantom of the Opera: The Original Novel
by Gaston Leroux
See this at Amazon.com

3 people are consuming this.

123 people have consumed this.


See all 123 people who have consumed this

People consuming this are also consuming these items.

3 entries have been written about this.

A review of this — 4 years ago

NOT WORTH CONSUMING

This is one of those rare instances when the adaptation is better than the book.

The premise is great. But the execution just didn’t do the premise justice. Character development is virtually non-existent, the prose is tedious, and the narration simply falls flat. I wouldn’t have finished this if not for the musical. I just kept flipping hoping that some climax would be reached in the following page, but nothing came. To be honest, I am quite amazed by how the writer actually managed to turn a potentially compelling story into something so bland and unreadable. (Well, but then again, if I had written the book, it might have turned out the same, if not worse.)

I’d say, stick with the musical, stay away from the book.

A story about this — 7 years ago

July 2004 book club section for www.eaforums.com.

A story about this — 8 years ago

12/23/2003

Listened to it on CD on the way up to Ohio.


FAQ | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Send Us Feedback | Robot Co-op Blog | Copyright © 2004 - 2012 Robot Co-op

or
Login with Facebook