Matthew McConaughey was fairly new on the scene and Sandra Bullock hadn’t done much either before this. McConaughey brings an earnest quality that’s perfect for the role. But what really stands out is the performance by Samuel L. Jackson.

What I love about this movie is that it’s not “Did he do it?” but “Was he justified?” Pay particular attention to Brigance’s closing argument—what a brilliant, evocative speech. You’ll know the one I’m talking about when it gets there.

I love courtroom dramas, and damn if I’m not on my feet, stamping and shouting at the screen every time I watch this movie. Very, very well done.