NYCinephile
New York City
Tasteful, But Not Engaging — 43 weeks ago
Throughout virtually the entire film, I was reminded of how utterly tasteful it was….it features tasteful performances, tasteful cinematography, tasteful music, tasteful settings and tasteful costumes. That doesn’t mean that it is dramatic or engaging, though.
I felt that that the film only came to life during the conflict in the small flat, and during Vanessa Redgrave’s monologue at the conclusion. That scene alone reveals what a great actress she is…every flicker of her eyes, the biting of her lip, conveys emotion. Her face tells so many stories.
The film features a beautiful continuous tracking shot that reminded me of the showstopper from Goodfellas.

Comments
Emily
Houston
Ah, Vanessa Redgrave...
I really wanted to see her on Broadway in The Year of Magical Thinking.
Sorry to hear that Atonement was kind of a letdown, though. The trailer looked really good, and I’ve heard rave reviews about the novel.
NYCinephile
New York City
Let me know...
...when you’ve seen it. I’d like to hear your thoughts.
denises
The novel is good, and I would have rated the movie 4 stars. Maybe it’s a bit more difficult to follow if you haven’t read the book. That’s the impression I’m getting.
hawkeyevigo
Vigo
English film in a big house is a big no no,you’re right about the Redgrave scene,even if I do despise her she can act.