A story about this — 6 years ago
disclaimr: I only read the first 70 pages…
Pretty much Mr. Faulks read “The Red and the Black” by Stendahl, and decided to copy the entire plot of the book, nix all the social, moral and political commentary that made Stendahl’s book great, and replace it with trashy romance scenes that only a male who has no idea what women are thinking could create, such as when he tells us that the female lead orgasms by having her breasts groped. (This being just one detail that was so rediculous I couldn’t beleive he wrote it. There are other more explicit details that are equally rediculous such as the novel’s heroine getting off on feeling cum run down her legs hours after having an affair with a man 10 years her junior.) Right Mr. Faulks, you wish. If you’re in the mood for something good, just read the Red and the Black. If you’re in the mood for some trashy romance, then opt for chick lit, as the sex scenes are at least believable and not imbarrasingly ignorant on the part of the author


Comments
Jul 07, 05:41AM
brriamcold
thanks for the comment
I will try to read it (past the first 70 pages!) eventually. I know I must have missed something, since it is called such a good book by so many people (and booklists). Thanks for the helpful comment, hopefully it will re-inspire me to try the novel again. My problem with the sex scenes wasn’t so much that it was explicit or animalistic, but for me it wasn’t written convincingly. As I was reading the scene, I just didn’t believe that this is what the female character would think- it just sounded like a male fantasizing about what women might think about and then writing it down. It didn’t seem like the author did very much research on how women are sexually different from men in terms of arousal and thoughts/emotions. But anyways, thanks for the comment!
Bkwrmish
Talk about ignorance...
Ms. “brriamcold” can’t spell…
…it’s “imbarrasingly ignorant” that she can’t spell “embarrassingly” correctly;
…and it is “rediculous” that she can’t spell “ridiculous” correctly.
Just sayin’. ;)
Add a comment